By JONAH MARTIN, NMC Project Management Office (PMO) Manager
Even by the standards of other major utility construction projects across the nation, the numbers behind Tri-State’s recently completed, 230-kilovolt Montrose-Nucla-Cahone (MNC) transmission project are staggering. Throw in a worldwide pandemic during the construction phase, and we have a real story to tell.
To be sure, the basic facts are impressive for a project built in remote areas of the Rocky Mountain West. The project began in May 2013 and required the approval of nearly a dozen local, state and federal agencies, including the U.S. Bureau of Land Management, the U.S. Forest Service, the U.S. Fish, and Wildlife Service, the Colorado Public Utilities Commission, and Colorado Parks and Wildlife.
MNC traversed more than 80 miles of often challenging terrain, and the associated severe weather, through portions of Dolores, Montrose, Ouray, and San Miguel counties in Colorado, at times reaching elevations of more than 11,000 feet above sea level.
The MNC included a substation expansion in Montrose, completed in May 2017; the new Maverick Substation, which Tri-State energized in April 2020; and improvements at the Cahone Substation.
Maverick Substation was to initially operate at 115 kilovolts (kV), while accommodating a future need for 69 kV service. The decision last year to decommission Tri-State’s Nucla Station power plant and the associated Nucla Substation earlier than planned required the Maverick Substation to take place earlier as part of the initial construction phase.
Transmission Lines and Fiber Optics
The transmission line project also included more than 300 miles of access improvements and significant vegetation management along nearly 60 miles of federal land. In total, MNC required 435 wood structures and 131 steel structures; 1.37 million feet of conductor, and nearly 475,000 feet of optical ground wire. The optical ground wire is part of the regional fiber optic communications backbone between Grand Junction and Albuquerque. Even these figures do not begin to tell the whole story.
The crowning achievement of this challenging project included the crossing of the historic Dolores Canyon just east of Dove Creek, Colo. The Dolores Canyon, characterized by red Wingate Sandstone, old-growth Ponderosa trees and the winding Dolores River, begins in the southern San Juan Mountains and meanders toward the Utah border. The Juan Rivera expedition viewed the Dolores Canyon in 1765 while exploring trade routes in Ute Country.
Dolores Canyon a Significant Crossing
For Tri-State, the crossing of the Dolores Canyon presented several unparalleled challenges in the U.S. transmission industry, with the exception of the smaller, original existing 115-kilovolt wood-frame crossing of the canyon completed in 1958. Even if the Gateway Arch in St. Louis were placed in the 1,100-foot canyon, it would not be visible, except to someone standing on the rim of the canyon.
The Tri-State crossing effort required a span of nearly 6,600 feet between two 85-foot-tall lattice towers on the north and south rim of the canyon. When counting distances from the “dead ends,” which hold the weight of each of the five 20,000 pounds of conductor and optical ground wire tensions, the distance was 8,000 feet. The line dropped some 400 feet between the lattice towers into the canyon.
Tri-State made five crossings of the canyon, three with conductor and two with optical ground wire. A helicopter first pulled a 5/16th inch rope from the south to the north end of the canyon, and then winch equipment pulled back a 3/4th inch rope back to the south. At that point, the rope then pulled the conductor and optical ground wire back from the south to the north rim. This work started starting during the week of Sept. 28 and was completed by Oct. 10.
To put some of this in perspective, the transmission line over the Dolores Canyon is about 1.25 miles between lattice towers and more than 1.5 miles between the dead ends. Only three other spans worldwide are known to be longer, although on much larger towers: an 8,714-span between the Jintang and Cezi islands in China; the crossing of the Norwegian Sognefjord at 15,082 feet; and the Ameralik Span in Greenland at 17,638 feet.
In fact, the Dolores Canyon segment wasn't the only significant crossing. Another canyon crossing was also significant. Workers previously had crossed Glade Canyon 2.5 miles north of Dolores Canyon, which was a 2,800-foot crossing, or just over half a mile, and would have been a significant effort for any other transmission line project but only the second largest on MNC.
The Montrose-Nucla-Cahone Transmission Line Project Benefits
The Montrose-Nucla-Cahone transmission line was energized in October and will be complete, aside from reclamation work by the end of the year. The project cost nearly $105 million and required 65,000 labor hours for construction.
Completion of this project brings a number of immediate benefits to Tri-State and the bulk electric system. Greater reliability and lower maintenance needs, greater operational capacity and flexibility, and the ability to accommodate load growth in the area are just a few of the immediate impacts. MNC also paves the way for future benefits, including the ability to support Tri-State’s Responsible Energy Plan and the growing interest in generation interconnection projects throughout western Colorado.
Numerous departments and dozens of employees throughout Tri-State have left their mark on this once-in-a-career project. Without the hard work and dedication of the MNC project team, none of the amazing numbers, accomplishments, and benefits could have been achieved. It has been an honor to work with such an amazing group and I look forward to a post-pandemic world when an appropriate celebration can take place.
Tri-State is a not-for-profit cooperative of 45 members, including 42 member utility electric distribution cooperatives and public power districts in four states, that together deliver reliable, affordable and responsible power to more than a million electricity consumers across nearly 200,000 square miles of the West. For more information about Tri-State and our Responsible Energy Plan, visit www.tristate.coop.